Tankless vs. 50-Gallon Water Heater: Which One Is Right for Your Idaho Home?
- Just Water Heaters LLC
- Sep 5
- 2 min read
Replacing a water heater isn’t something most homeowners do often, but when the time comes, the decision feels big. Do you stick with a traditional 50-gallon tank or upgrade to a tankless system? While tankless models come with a higher upfront cost, they also bring major benefits that can make them the smarter long-term choice for many Idaho households.
Let’s break down the differences so you can decide which is best for your home.
How They Work
50-Gallon Tank Water Heater – Stores and reheats water continuously. Once you’ve used up the hot water, you’ll need to wait for the tank to refill and reheat.
Tankless Water Heater – Provides hot water on demand. Instead of storing it, the system instantly heats water as it flows through, delivering an endless supply.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
Tankless Water Heater
✅ Endless hot water, never run out mid-shower
✅ Energy-efficient, no standby heat loss
✅ Compact design saves floor space
✅ Lasts up to 20+ years with proper maintenance
❌ Higher upfront installation cost
❌ May require upgrades to gas or electrical systems
50-Gallon Tank Water Heater
✅ Lower upfront cost
✅ Straightforward installation and repairs
✅ Reliable performance
❌ Hot water can run out with back-to-back showers
❌ Shorter lifespan (10–12 years)
❌ Higher monthly utility bills due to constant reheating
The Cost
For most homeowners, cost is the biggest factor. A 50-gallon tank water heater is typically less expensive to purchase and install, making it the go-to choice for budget-conscious families or rental properties.
Tankless systems, while more expensive upfront, are designed for efficiency and longevity. They often lower utility bills over time and can last nearly twice as long as a tank. For households planning to stay in their home for many years, the long-term savings and convenience often outweigh the initial investment.
Lifestyle Considerations
Large families or high hot water demand? Tankless is ideal, keeping up with multiple showers or appliances running at the same time.
Smaller households or short-term living situation? A 50-gallon tank may be perfectly adequate.
Space a concern? Tankless units free up valuable floor space by mounting on the wall.
Maintenance Needs
Both types require regular care to perform their best:
Tank models should be flushed annually to prevent sediment buildup.
Tankless units require descaling and filter cleaning, especially in areas with hard water.
Which Should You Choose?
If you’re looking for the most affordable upfront option, a 50-gallon tank water heater is a reliable choice. But if you want endless hot water, lower monthly bills, and a system built to last decades, tankless is worth the investment.
If you're still on the fence or would like to know more, we are happy to provide a free consultation and discuss all options with you to find out what is best for you.
Ready to Upgrade?
At Just Water Heaters, we specialize in helping homeowners choose the right system for their needs and budget. Whether you go with a tank or tankless, our certified experts will handle installation with care and precision.
Contact us today for a free estimate and let’s find the perfect water heater for your home.
Comments